# What We Can and Cannot Verify

By Ruth Calder, Enforcement Editor (https://glpwatchdog.org/authors/ruth-calder) | Published: 2026-08-19 | Updated: 2026-10-27

Canonical page: https://glpwatchdog.org/research/what-we-can-and-cannot-verify

> Five errors found in our own live pages in one week, all named. Plus the standing limits: 182 unverified LegitScript claims, 324 sellers with no state list, and the things nobody can check from outside.

## Key points

- Four sellers were credited with FDA warning letters they do not have. Corrected.
- One was criticized for a price that turned out to be brand Ozempic, not compounded.
- 182 LegitScript claims remain unverified because their lookup is CAPTCHA-protected.
- Generated text fails silently, at scale, and reads well while doing it.

Every site that ranks sellers tells you what it knows. This is the other half: what we cannot check, what we get wrong, and what we found wrong in our own pages in a single week of August 2026. If you are going to rely on a register, you should know where its edges are.

## Five things we published that were wrong

All five were live. All five have been corrected, and each now has an automated check that fails our build if it recurs.

1. **Four sellers were credited with FDA warning letters they do not have** (four, five and six of them). The count was built from a field that also stored general FDA notes, so boilerplate about compounded drugs not being FDA-approved was counted as enforcement history. [Written up here](https://glpwatchdog.org/research/what-186-fda-warning-letters-say).
2. **One seller’s review said it “carries a LegitScript certification”** while the body of the same page said the certification was absent. The flag searched the whole record for the word, so a note saying a seal was *missing* counted as proof one existed. [Written up here](https://glpwatchdog.org/research/what-a-legitscript-badge-tells-you).
3. **One seller was publicly criticized for charging “273% above the register median for compounded semaglutide”** when the price in question was brand Ozempic, quoted verbatim from its own site in our notes. [Written up here](https://glpwatchdog.org/research/how-much-glp1-prices-actually-vary).
4. **Eleven sellers offered a molecule the FDA says cannot lawfully be compounded, and three had it written up as a selling point**, a “broad GLP-1 menu”. [Written up here](https://glpwatchdog.org/research/what-cannot-legally-be-compounded).
5. **Two public filters were labeled “LegitScript verified only”**, asserting a verification we have never performed on a single record.

> Four sellers were credited with FDA warning letters they do not have, and one with a LegitScript certification its own page said was absent.

## What we cannot verify at all

Some limits are structural, and more care will not fix them.

*Standing limits on what this register can establish, as counted in August 2026.*

| Claim | What we can actually say |
| --- | --- |
| LegitScript certification | 182 sellers claim it. We have verified none — LegitScript’s lookup is protected by a CAPTCHA, which is reasonable of them and means it can only be checked by hand. |
| Which states a seller operates in | 324 of 556 publish no list at all. We cannot confirm coverage a seller does not state. |
| Price | 111 publish none. Those that do change them, and our figure is only as fresh as its check date. |
| Whether a pharmacy actually made your vial | Nobody can establish this from outside. FDA has found labels naming pharmacies that do not exist. |
| Before-and-after photographs | Unverifiable in principle. There is no registry of them. |

## How the errors were found

None was found by review. Every one surfaced while writing an article that needed a number: counting sellers offering a molecule, computing a price spread, checking who claims a badge. The act of publishing a figure is what exposed the figure being wrong.

That suggests the errors still in here will be found the same way, by someone computing something. It also means the parts of the register nobody has needed a number from are the parts least likely to have been checked.

> **One class of error is specific to how this site is built.** Several of our published sentences are generated from structured data rather than written by hand, which is what lets hundreds of reviews stay current. It also means a single wrong rule produces a wrong sentence on many pages at once, and produces it in confident, fluent prose.

## What you should do with any register, including this one

- **Check the date on anything that moves.** Prices and terms change faster than any register updates.
- **Treat an absence as an absence.** “No FDA letter on record” means we searched a register, not that nothing exists anywhere.
- **Verify anything that would change your decision.** Checking a badge, a price or a state list takes minutes, and we publish how to do each.
- **Tell us when we are wrong.** Every correction above came from the inside, which is the least reliable way for it to happen.

Our [corrections page](https://glpwatchdog.org/corrections) lists changes we have made, and [the methodology page](https://glpwatchdog.org/methodology) sets out how scores are computed. Neither makes exciting reading, but both are more useful than a ranking.

## Frequently asked questions

### Does this site make mistakes?

Yes, and five were found in live pages in a single week, including four sellers credited with FDA warning letters they do not have, and one criticized for a price that was brand-name rather than compounded. All are corrected and each now has an automated check behind it.

### Are the LegitScript claims on this site verified?

No. When we counted in August 2026, 182 sellers carried a LegitScript claim inherited when this register was created, and we had independently confirmed none of them. LegitScript's own lookup is protected by a CAPTCHA, so the claims can only be checked by hand, one at a time.

### Why do errors happen at scale here?

Because many published sentences are generated from structured data rather than written individually, which is what keeps hundreds of reviews current. The trade-off is that one wrong rule produces a wrong sentence on many pages simultaneously, in fluent prose that reads perfectly well.

### How were the mistakes found?

By writing articles that needed numbers. Errors surfaced while counting sellers, computing a price spread and checking who claims a badge; the act of publishing a figure is what exposed the figure being wrong. That implies the least-examined parts of the register are the ones nobody has needed a number from.

### What should I verify myself?

Anything that would change your decision: a badge, a price, whether a seller operates in your state. Those checks take minutes, and we publish how to do each of them.

## References

1. GLP Watchdog. Corrections and methodology — errors identified in published pages during August 2026, and the standing limits on what the register can verify. GLP Watchdog. 2026. https://glpwatchdog.org/corrections

---

Cite as: GLP Watchdog, Ruth Calder, "What We Can and Cannot Verify", published 2026-08-19, updated 2026-10-27. https://glpwatchdog.org/research/what-we-can-and-cannot-verify

Canonical HTML page: https://glpwatchdog.org/research/what-we-can-and-cannot-verify

Medical disclaimer: Nothing here is medical advice. We report on this subject; we do not treat anyone. Whether to begin a medication, supplement, or treatment, whether to adjust it, and whether to stop are questions for a clinician licensed to answer them, who knows your history.
